top of page
Mountain Ridge

Mind, Body, and Blog

Empowering insights and distractions for our journeys

Are You Feeling Something, or Telling Yourself a Story?

3 days ago
5 min read

You send a text to someone you care about. A few hours pass, and there's no reply.


At first, you barely notice. Then you check your phone. Maybe you feel a little uneasy. You check again. By evening, your mind has started filling in the blanks.


Did I say something wrong? Are they upset with me? Maybe I matter less to them than I thought.


Photo Credit: Faruk Tokluoğlu https://www.pexels.com/@faruktokluoglu/
Photo Credit: Faruk Tokluoğlu https://www.pexels.com/@faruktokluoglu/

You feel hurt, anxious, or irritated. You consider sending a sharp follow-up, or not reaching out again.


But all you know for certain is that they haven't replied. The rest is an interpretation. It may be correct, but you don't know yet.


The trouble begins when we start treating what we imagine might be happening as though we know it's true.


What We Feel and What We Think


We often talk about emotions, feelings, and thoughts as though they're interchangeable. They're closely connected, but distinguishing them can be useful.


An emotion involves a response to something we perceive as significant. That response may include changes in attention, bodily sensations, impulses, and brain activity. Our breathing might become shallow, our stomach might tighten, or we might feel an urge to withdraw or argue.


A feeling is our conscious experience of an emotional state: sadness, fear, anger, joy, or something harder to name. We can feel something without immediately having the right word for it.


A thought is how we interpret, explain, or make sense of what's happening. They're ignoring me. This isn't fair. I'm going to lose this relationship.


These aren't neatly separated steps. Thoughts, emotions, and bodily sensations continually influence one another. Still, it helps to ask: What am I experiencing, and what am I concluding?


Consider the difference between saying, "I feel hurt," and "I feel like you don't respect me." The hurt is an emotional experience. The belief that someone doesn't respect you is an interpretation of their behavior. It might be accurate, but it's still something worth examining.


That distinction isn't meant to dismiss anyone's experience. It's meant to give us more room to understand it.


How a Story Takes Shape


Our minds are constantly trying to make sense of the world. They use memories, expectations, past experiences, and whatever information is available to anticipate what might happen next.


That's useful, but it also means our interpretations are influenced by what we've lived through.


If you've experienced rejection, silence may register as a warning sign. If you've frequently been criticized, a casual remark may sound like an attack. If you've spent years trying to keep the peace, someone else's disappointment may feel like an emergency.


None of this means you're imagining your emotions. The anxiety or hurt may be very real. But the explanation your mind reaches for may not tell the whole story.


And once a story takes hold, it can feed the emotion that helped produce it.


You feel uneasy because the text goes unanswered. You think, They're pulling away from me. That thought increases your anxiety. Now the anxiety seems to confirm that something must be wrong. You check your phone again, and the cycle continues.


What began as uncertainty has become something that feels remarkably like certainty.


Your Feelings Matter. So Does the Evidence.


There's a risk here that I want to be careful about. Asking someone to examine their story can sound like telling them not to trust themselves. That's not the point.


Sometimes people really are being dismissive. Sometimes a relationship is unhealthy. Sometimes anger tells us a boundary has been crossed. We shouldn't explain away genuine problems simply because emotions are involved.


But we can also take our feelings seriously without treating our first explanation as a proven fact.


A feeling can tell us that something matters to us. It doesn't always tell us exactly why it happened, what another person intended, or what we should do next.


Imagine the person eventually replies, "I'm sorry. My phone died, and today got away from me." Your earlier anxiety was real, but now you have new information.


Now imagine a different situation: someone repeatedly ignores important messages and refuses to discuss it. That pattern deserves attention too. Being curious about our interpretations doesn't require us to overlook what the evidence actually shows.


We can take our emotions seriously while remaining open to the possibility that we don't have the whole picture."


Four Practices for Responding Rather Than Reacting


We can't always prevent an emotional response, and we don't need to. But we can practice creating a little more space between an experience and our next action.


1. Notice what's happening.


Before trying to solve the situation, pay attention to your body. Is your chest tight? Are your shoulders raised? Is your jaw clenched? Do you feel restless or unusually quiet?


You don't have to analyze every sensation. Simply recognizing that you're becoming activated may help you avoid acting on the first impulse. If you're highly upset, it may help to step away, take a comfortable slow breath, walk briefly, or let your body settle before continuing.


2. Name what you're feeling.


Try putting a few words to the experience: I'm hurt. I'm anxious. I'm embarrassed. I'm angry. You may discover that more than one feeling is present. Anger, for instance, can coexist with fear or disappointment.


Research on putting feelings into words suggests that identifying and naming what we're feeling may help reduce emotional reactivity. It won't resolve every problem, but it can help us recognize what we're dealing with rather than immediately acting it out.


3. Examine the story.


Ask yourself: What do I know? What am I assuming? What other explanations are possible? What information might I be missing?


This doesn't mean forcing yourself to find a positive explanation. "They're probably busy" is just another guess if you don't know. The more honest answer may be, "I don't know why they haven't responded yet."


That uncertainty can be uncomfortable. It can also be more accurate than the conclusion you reached while upset.


4. Choose what happens next.


Once you've noticed your reaction and questioned your assumptions, consider what response would be helpful and consistent with the kind of person you want to be.


Maybe you give the person more time. Maybe you send a simple follow-up. Maybe you have a direct conversation about a pattern that's troubling you. Or maybe you decide that you need to establish a boundary.


The point isn't to avoid conflict or difficult conversations. Sometimes responding well means speaking up, setting a boundary, or addressing something that needs to change. But we can do those things with firmness and respect rather than anger or harshness.


What changes is that we're acting with greater intention rather than letting the first wave of emotion decide for us.


A Little More Space, a Little More Choice


None of this is easy, especially when emotions are intense or a situation touches an old wound. Sometimes our nervous system is so activated that reflection isn't immediately available. That's when tending to our physical state, seeking support, or taking time before responding may be the wisest first step.


And sometimes we won't get it right. We'll send the sharp text, become defensive, or assume we know what someone meant. When that happens, we can still pause, reconsider, and repair what needs repairing.


The goal isn't to stop feeling, become perfectly rational, or question every emotion that arises. It's to learn that what we're feeling and what we're telling ourselves about it aren't always the same thing.


Our feelings deserve attention. Our interpretations deserve curiosity. And our actions deserve a little intention.


The next time you notice yourself getting caught up in a difficult moment, you might ask: What am I feeling right now? And what story am I telling myself about why?


That small distinction may give you just enough space to choose what happens next.

 
 
 

Comments


  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
IMG-3774.jpg

About Don

Don is a highly skilled and experienced professor and counselor with a deep passion for helping others achieve their full potential. With decades of hands-on experience working with thousands of clients, students, and organizations, Don has developed a unique approach to counseling and coaching that is rooted in transformational and empowering conversations. When he's not helping others unlock their full potential, Don can often be found indulging in his passions for bicycling and camping. Based out of the Portland, OR area, Don is dedicated to helping his clients address humanity's most pressing problems and tap into their own inner strengths and resources.

Join the Mindful Living Newsletter

Sky

STAY IN THE KNOW

Thanks for submitting!

Sierra is just getting started. Stay on top of transformative blog posts, articles, free content, updates, and more. My newsletter will not only provide compelling material but also point towards helpful resources and practices that can change the way you live and feel. It's safe and your information is never shared. Sign up now.

bottom of page